• About
  • End of Year ‘Best Of’ Lists
    • ‘Best Film’ Lists
      • Film – 2017
      • Film – 2016
      • Film – 2015
      • Film – 2014
      • Film – 2013
      • Film – 2012
      • Film – 2011
    • ‘Best TV’ Lists
      • TV – 2017
      • TV – 2016
      • TV – 2015
      • TV – 2014
      • TV – 2013
      • TV – 2012
      • TV – 2011
  • Archived TV Recaps & Reviews
    • Canadian TV
      • Being Erica
      • Between
      • Bitten
      • Lost Girl
      • Orphan Black

Queer.Horror.Movies

The curated portfolio of film journalist Joe Lipsett

  • Queer
    • Horror Queers
    • Inside/Out Film Festival
    • Queer TV
      • American Horror Story
      • In The Flesh
      • Lost Girl
      • Pose
      • Sense8
      • Transparent
  • Horror
    • He Said/She Said
    • Horror Film Festival Coverage
      • Boston Underground Film Festival
      • Fantasia Film Festival
      • Hexploitation Film Festival
      • Horror-on-Sea
      • MidWest Weirdfest
      • Spring of Horror
      • Toronto After Dark
    • Horror Film Reviews
      • He Said/She Said Film Reviews
    • Horror TV
      • American Horror Story
      • Ash vs Evil Dead
      • Into The Dark
      • iZombie
      • Kingdom
      • Penny Dreadful
      • Scream
      • The Outsider
    • Horror Writing For External Websites
  • Movies
    • Hazel & Katniss & Harry & Starr Podcast
    • Film Reviews
      • Christmas Films
    • Film Festivals
      • Toronto International Film Festival
  • Podcasts
    • Hazel & Katniss & Harry & Starr Podcast
    • Horror Queers
    • XOXO Horror Podcast
    • Guest Appearances
  • Live Appearances

Quick Take: The Secret Circle – 1×08: ‘Beneath’

November 4, 2011 by Joe Lipsett

Courtesy of The CW

As the first season of not-quite-Vampire-Diaries-level teen drama chugs along, we’re settling into a rhythm: random spookiness, investigation by the circle, followed by mildly threatening danger and a likely cliffhanger ending.

This week’s episode, featuring a road trip to Faye Chamberlain’s (Phoebe Tonkin) family cottage in search of Cassie Blake’s (Britt Robertson) missing grandmother, Jane (Ashley Crow), provided a few interesting narrative developments, but the forward momentum of the last few weeks took a backseat to a more traditional ghost story.

Halloween seems to have done wonders for most shows, including this one. The witch hunting storyline, although rushed, was an exciting step forward: it not only built on the demon story that got Nick (Louis Hunter) killed  in ‘Slither’, but revealed that the series is working with a larger storytelling canvas than the three generations of witches we’ve met in Chance Harbour. Much like recent developments on Revenge, the stakes for this coven have been raised as they’ve already lost a member, and now they’re being hunted.

Unfortunately this week most of this was sidelined in favour of a primarily stand alone episode that explored the issues affecting the group – minus dead weight Melissa (Jessica Parker Kennedy) who thankfully got the night off. The episode, playing a bit like a haunted house wherein objects appeared and disappeared, confined the action to a single location so that characters could confront each other to work out their issues. And so a quick game of truth or dare brought tensions between Faye, Cassie and good-girl, Diana (Shelley Hennig) to a boil; Adam and Diana continued through their break up with some woodshed make-up sex, and Jake (Chris Zylka) continued to gather information on the group and fall for Cassie.

For the most part the action was obvious, especially when the B storyline with parents Dawn (Natasha Henstridge) and Charles Meade (Gale Harold) continually reinforced how important it was that the kids not discover dead grandpa, Henry Chamberlain  (Tom Butler). Obviously that was exactly what happened, so the reveal was decidedly anticlimatic, although watching Cassie boil water to raise Henry’s body was a fun visual.

In all this was a placeholder episode designed to move our characters into place for next week’s mid-season finale, but it wasn’t the strongest episode (nor the most engaging). We’ll have to wait to see whether the Jake drama, and Charles’ power-tripping new crystal, pays off.

Other observations:

  • How will grandma Jane’s amnesia/mind-control affect her ability to help the teens?
  • Does anyone else hope that the show takes a page from The Vampire Diaries and defies expectations instead of going the obvious route where Jake betrays Isaac (JR Bourne) to defend the circle? Or that *SPECULATIVE SPOILER* Isaac will take his revenge by kidnapping Cassie (as hinted in the preview)?
  • Did anyone miss absent-witch Melissa? Anyone? Bueller?

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
  • Click to share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Click to print (Opens in new window) Print

Like this:

Like Loading...

Filed Under: The Secret Circle, TV Tagged With: Britt Robertson, Gale Harold, Natasha Henstridge, The CW, TV

Trackbacks

  1. Quick Take: The Secret Circle – 1×09: ‘Balcoin’ | Bitch Stole My Remote says:
    November 11, 2011 at 11:29 am

    […] As predicted last week, the episode was centered on whether or not Chris Zylka’s Jake would betray the coven to the witchhunters that accompanied him to Chance Harbour following the death of his brother, Nick. In last week’s ‘Beneath’ players were moved around the chessboard to prepare for the events in ‘Balcoin’: Diana (Shelley Hennig) declared her relationship with Adam (Thomas Dekker) over, Cassie made a move on Jake despite Faye’s (Phoebe Tonkin) lingering feelings for him, and in the adult storyline, Charles (Gale Harold) wiped clean Jane’s (Ashley Crow) memory. […]

  2. The Secret Circle recap – 1×12: ‘Witness’ « Bitch Stole My Remote says:
    January 20, 2012 at 1:14 pm

    […] Cassie simply says it’s the same process she and Faye used at her grandfather’s cabin back in 1×08 “Beneath.” I only really cared because this finally allows Thomas Dekker a chance to deliver a comedic line […]

The 411 on me

I am a freelance film and television journalist based in Toronto, Canada.

Words:
> Bloody Disgusting
> /Film
> Consequence
> The Spool
> Anatomy of a Scream
> Grim Journal
> That Shelf

Podcasts:
> Horror Queers
> Hazel & Katniss & Harry & Starr

Recent Posts

  • ‘Weapons’ Review – The Visceral Impact of Zach Cregger’s Latest Only Lasts ‘Til The Lights Come On
  • ‘Freakier Friday’ Review – Fewer Laughs, Same Big Heart
  • 4K Review: ‘Frailty’ (2001)

Copyright © 2025 · Metro Pro Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

%d